Are you one of those that have a sweet tooth? Do you often crave bakery items such as cakes? Alongside that, do the process of baking a large cake, and the overall waiting process make you go out and grab one from bakery shops?

Well, in that case, you should get into baking cake pops. They are simple but yet highly customizable, just like regular cakes.

Even though the idea of baking them might sound quite intriguing, you are not going to get the optimal result without the best cake pop maker. Now you might ask that with all the options, how will you get a decent one out of them? Well, you will not have to worry about that cause we got you covered in that regard.


 


5 Best Cake Pop Maker Reviews

As we mentioned above, there is an overabundance of cake pop makers in the market. And it would get you bewildered while trying to choose one for your baking needs among all of them.

For making the choosing process easier for you, we went through all the popular ones and picked only the ones that stood out the most to us. They are:

1. Health and Home Multifunction Nonstick Baking Maker

Health and Home Multifunction Nonstick Baking Maker

When it comes to versatility, there are hardly a few in the market that match up with this one that Health and Home is offering. That is why it boasts the term ‘Multifunction’ in its label.

The unit comes with three different interchangeable trays. Let us talk about the highlighting plate first, which has 24 holes in it. That means you will be able to bake thirty cake pops with this in a single session.

Other than that, it also comes with a baking tray that has six holes in it. And there is a flat baking tray included in the package as well. The inclusion of all of these trays makes it exceptionally versatile.

Besides that, the unit comes with a built-in thermostat. The temperature control mechanism works automatically, but you will be able to regulate it with the integrated ring tube that it comes along. With that, you will have full control over the bakery items that you will bake on it.

The trays come with nonstick coating on the surface. Because of this coating, you will be able to use a low amount of cooking coil for baking cakes on it. It will also make it easier for you to take them off the tray after they are cooked properly.

Alongside that, as the tray has a nonstick coating, you will not have to worry about embedded food residues as well. You can clean it easily.

Pros

  • Exceptionally versatile
  • The cake pop tray has 24 slots
  • Boasts built-in thermostat
  • Plates have a nonstick coating on them
  • Easy to clean

Cons

  • Body feels a bit cheap
  • Trays tend not to heat evenly

2. Babycakes Mini Cake Pop Maker

Babycakes Mini Cake Pop Maker

You might not want to get something that is versatile. Instead, you might want to opt for something that is for cake pops only. Well, Babycakes has got you covered in that regard.

As we mentioned, the unit is exceptionally simple and straightforward. It comes with a tray that has nine slots. That means you will be able to make nine pop cakes in one go.

Keeping the tabs up with the other units, this one also comes with a nonstick coating on the surface. Because of this nonstick coating, you will not have to worry about your food getting stuck in the tray. The cleaning process will also get much easier if the food does not get embedded on the surface.

On the bottom, it comes with rubber feet. These non-skid feet will make sure that the unit does not move from one place to another. Alongside that, it also comes with a latching handle, which will make sure that you can close the lid properly, and the temperature inside gets evenly distributed.

You will also not have to worry about the power cord dangling around because it comes with a cord wrap. With that, you will be able to keep the cord organized and store it properly when you are not using it.

Lastly, there is a power light on top of the lid that will let you know when the unit is powered on.

Pros

  • The plate has a nonstick coating
  • Easy to clean
  • Features latching handle
  • Comes with non-skid rubber feet
  • Can make nine pop cakes at one go

Cons

  • Does not have any sort of temperature control mechanism
  • The size of the slots are relatively small

3. Holstein Housewares Full Size Cupcake Maker

Holstein Housewares Full Size Cupcake Maker

While going through the cake pop maker reviews, you might want to go for something that is compact but can make a large number of pops at one go. In that case, you should put what Holstein Housewares is offering into your consideration.

Even though the label states that the unit is a cupcake maker, the slots are in such a way that you will be able to make large-sized cake pop in it. In fact, you can make 12 of them at one go. With this, baking pops for a large number of people will not be an issue.

Like the other units, this one also features a nonstick coating on the tray. Because of that, you will be able to get fluffy cakes on it by using a comparatively lower amount of oil. The coating will also make sure that food residues do not stick on the surface.

It comes with a built-in safety lock that will allow you to close the lid securely. The lock will also make sure that the slots can make a proper seal, and the temperature inside gets distributed evenly.

To keep it secure on top of a table, it comes with rubber feet on the bottom. The non-slip feet will keep it stable on top and will not allow it to move from one place to another. And, as it comes featuring a compact body, you will not have to worry about running out of space on your countertop as well.

Pros

  • Features a compact body
  • Can make 12 pops at one go
  • Sports a nonstick cooking plate
  • Comes with a safety lock mechanism
  • Boasts non-slip rubber feets

Cons

  • The top of the cakes tend to burn relatively fast
  • Not that easy to clean

4. CucinaPro Takoyaki Pan and Ebelskiver Maker

CucinaPro Takoyaki Pan and Ebelskiver Maker

Having numerous amount of slots is great and all, but if the unit can not be cleaned properly, maintaining the device would be quite a hassle. CucinaPro kept that in mind and brought out this unit in the market.

To begin with, it has seven slots on the top. In those slots, you will be able to make cake pops and pancake puffs, Danish pancakes, and donuts. These slots make this unit exceptionally versatile.

As we mentioned, the surface of the unit has an efficient nonstick coating. For that, the slots will require relatively less amount of cooking oil. Alongside that, you will also be able to wipe them clean easily. Foods will not stick to the surface, and you can get them out without any issues at all.

Other than that, as the coating on the slots is of PFOE, you will not have to worry about the pops getting induced with harmful chemicals in your food. The slots can also distribute the heat uniformly, which will make sure that your food gets cooked evenly. You will not have to worry about serving uncooked dough to your guests.

The unit is quite easy to use too. It comes with a simple on-off switch. Besides that, the compact size will make it easier for you to store it when you are not baking on it.

Pros

  • Features an efficient nonstick surface
  • Can make a plethora of baking items
  • Sports seven cooking slots
  • Distributes the heat evenly
  • Effortless to use and easy to store

Cons

  • Does not have rubber feet on the bottom
  • The unit does not come with a lid

5. Brentwood Cake Pop Maker Non-Stick

Brentwood Cake Pop Maker Non-Stick

We are going to finish off our cake pop makers reviews with this unit that is from Brentwood. If you are looking for a powerful pop maker, then you should check this one out.

First of all, it features a powerful heating system that is rated at 750 watts. Because of that, it will be able to bake relatively faster than the other units that are out there. To be exact, it can cook all the pops in just four minutes.

Besides cooking faster, it can also make 12 pops at a single cooking session. The plate has twelve slots on it, and with that, you can bake for a large group of people without any issues at all.

The cooking surface features a nonstick coating, which will make it easier for you to take the food out of the slots. Alongside that, it will also make cleaning easier.

It also comes with a preheating system that will let you make the surface ready before you start baking. The status indicator will let you know when the slots are adequately preheated.

Other than that, it also comes with some built-in safety mechanisms as well. It will shut itself off if the surface overheats. You will not have to worry about your pops burning.

It comes with vertical feet on the bottom that will allow you to make it stand securely on flat countertops. The cable wrap will let you maneuver the cable around easily. It will also make storing it hassle-free.

Pros

  • Features a powerful 750 watts heater
  • Can cook pops under 4 minutes
  • Boasts 12 slots
  • Comes with safety features
  • Includes a cable wrap for easy storing

Cons

  • Does not have any temperature control mechanism
  • The lid does not have a secure closing lock

Should You Let the Cake Cool Before Making Cake Pops?

Yes, you will have to let the cake cool before you put them on a maker. A simple instruction for making cake pop is as follows:

The first thing that you have to do is to preheat the cake pop maker. Then you should mix all the dry ingredients together. Use a medium bowl for storing all that and keep it aside for a couple of minutes.

Then you must whisk butter, sugar, egg, and vanilla extract. While whisking, you need to put all the dry ingredients in that mixture. Then you should let it cool completely in a fridge before making round balls.

Cake Pop Maker

After that, you will have to make balls with the mixture that you just made according to the size of the slots that your maker has. Coat the balls with some cooking oil and put them on the pop maker. You should end up with simple yet delicious cake pops. Customize that with other coatings that you prefer.

How Do I Choose a Cake Pop Maker?

After going through the cake pop makers reviews, you might already have an idea about the things that you can expect from a decent cake pop maker. Alongside that, you should also keep these factors in mind, which will help you make an efficient overall purchase:

Build Quality

First of all, you need to consider the build quality of the units. As you are going to bake on it quite frequently, you would want something that lasts for an extended amount of time, would you not?

Cake Pop Maker

That is why we would recommend you to opt for the ones that feature a well built, sturdy body. The ones that have an aluminum body would be a good option in this regard.

Number of Slots

After factoring in the build quality, you would also want to consider the number of slots that are on the cooking surface. The less the slots, the less amount of pops you will be able to make. And a unit that can bake fewer amount of pops at one go will make it a bit harder for you to make cake pops for a large group of people.

The Size of the Slots

You should also consider the size of the slots before making a purchase. The versatile ones, as in, the ones that can bake cupcakes and other bakery items, will usually have large-sized slots. So, if you are planning to make moderately-sized pops, you should check the size of the slots beforehand.

Nonstick Surface

Even though most of the units will come featuring a nonstick coating on the surface, not all of them will be efficient. The ones that are not that efficient will require relatively more amount of cooking oil.

Alongside that, you will also have a tough time trying to take off finished cake pops out of the slots. It will tend to have more food residues, which will also make the cleaning process a bit harder.

The Lid

Most of the units will feature an open design. However, some will come with a lid on the top that will ensure that the temperature gets distributed evenly. For those, what you have to consider is that if they have a secure locking mechanism or not.

If that is missing on the unit, then you will find that the top of the pops will be undercooked.

Rubber Feets

The last thing that you have to consider is if the unit comes with rubber feet on the bottom or not. If they are missing, your pop maker will slide from one place to another on a flat surface easily.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Are the versatile cake pop makers worth it?

According to us, the versatile units are definitely worth it. They will not only allow you to bake cake pops but also other bakery items. That means you are not going to have to buy a separate device for cooking them.

2. What else can I make on my cake pop maker?

Apart from cake pops, you will be able to make pancake puffs, Danish pancakes, and small-sized donuts on your cake pop maker. Many units will also allow you to bake small cupcakes.

3. How many slots should an average cake pop maker have?

Usually, the compact ones will have around six to seven slots. On the other hand, the large ones can have as much as thirty slots. With those, baking for a large number of people will feel like taking a walk in the park.

4. Why is my cake pop falling apart?

One of the reasons behind that would be that your pops are not round enough. If they are not round, they will not be able to hold its integrity. To eliminate this problem, you can use more frosting, which will help them to hold the shape.

5. What can I use instead of sticks?

If you do not have lollipop sticks in your inventory, you can use candy sticks, cinnamon sticks, and peppermint sticks. You can also insert a spoon after baking them.

Final Words

We hope that we were able to make it easier for you to choose the best cake pop maker for satisfying your sweet tooth. With that, we would wish to wrap things up here by wishing you good luck and hoping that the pops that you bake turn out delicious and are evenly cooked.