Muffins are a fun little snack that can bring a smile to the face. However, baking them without an adequate pan can be a bit challenging because you will not be able to make the dough rise perfectly.

And after you finally give up on the idea of cooking them at home, you will have to go to bakery stores to bring the smile back to your face.

But you do know that getting the best muffin pan will allow you to bake perfectly cooked muffins easily, right? If you did not, well, now you know. And, as you have found us, you will not have to worry about the hassles that come with choosing one. We are going to make it easier for you.


 


10 Best Muffin Pan Reviews

The overabundance of options in the market will surely get you bewildered. Well, to not let that happen to you, we have gone through the most popular options and huddled a list with the ones that are recommendation worthy. Take a look at the list that we made for you:

1. CHEFMADE Muffin Cake Pan

CHEFMADE Muffin Cake Pan

Are you tired of waiting for a long amount of time that muffins usually take in the oven? Want something that will accelerate the process? Well, CHEFMADE has got the right thing for you! And we are going to start our best muffin pan reviews with this one.

Let us talk about the highlighting feature first. The unit comes with a commercial-grade construction. It utilizes a 0.8-millimeter thick carbon steel body. Because of such thickness, it will not only be able to retain heat for an extended amount of time, but the heating process will also get accelerated.

Other than that, the unit comes with a silicone coating on the top. This coating is non-Teflon, PFOA, and PTFE free, and is food grade. You will not have to worry about your food getting induced with harmful chemicals.

It comes with a nonstick coating that is extremely efficient. You will be able to make your muffins rise properly using a little amount of cooking oil. Alongside that, you will not have any trouble in case of pulling them from the slots.

The nonstick coating also makes the cleaning process a bit easier. It will make sure that the food residues do not get embedded on the surface. You will not have to fight with a scrubber to get the surface and the slots clean.

It comes in three different slots options. You will be able to choose from 6 cups, 12 cups, and 20 cups pans. There are different slot size options too.

Pros

  • Features a durable carbon steel body
  • Able to retain heat exceptionally well
  • Comes with a food-grade silicone coating
  • Has an efficient nonstick surface
  • Comes in a different slot and slot-size options

Cons

  • Tends to warp after a few uses
  • Some units arrive with dents on the body

2. Trudeau Structured Silicone Muffin Pan

Trudeau Structured Silicone Muffin Pan

The one thing that sways people away from silicone muffin pan is the inability to be able to distribute the heat evenly to the slots. However, that will not be the case with this one.

Unlike most of the silicone pans, this one can evenly distribute the heat to each of the slots. Because of that, your muffins will rise up properly, and they will a beautiful look brown crust on top of them. For that reason, this one can easily be stated as the best silicone muffin pan models that you can find in the market.

Other than that, the unit also comes in different cup options. There are 6 cups large, 12 and 20 cups normal-sized, and 24 cups mini cup options available. Each of them also has four different color options that you will be able to choose from.

Even though the unit is of silicone, it will be able to hold its structure exceptionally well. It comes with an integrated steel frame that will allow you to easily carry it around even when you have food on it. You will not have to worry about it drooping on one side.

Besides that, the silicone construction also acts as a nonstick material. For that reason, you will be able to take the food off from the slots easily. It is also dishwasher safe, which means you will be able to clean it without any hassles at all.

Pros

  • Distributes heat evenly on the slots
  • Comes in three color options and four slot options
  • Dishwasher safe and easy to clean
  • Comes integrated with a steel frame
  • Has an efficient nonstick property induced in it

Cons

  • Muffins tend to burn a little on the bottom
  • Tends to leave a silicone taste into the food

3. Sweese 517.101 Porcelain Muffin Pan

Sweese 517.101 Porcelain Muffin Pan

Porcelain wares are commonly known for having a higher stain and scratch-resistant properties. And, if you want a muffin pan that is of that material, then your best bet would be this one that is from Sweese, which is also the best mini stick muffin pan.

Just like we mentioned above, the unit is of porcelain. This material is FDA approved is lead-free. That means you will not have to worry about it releasing toxic substances to your food.

Apart from being safe, the unit is quite durable. It is scratch resistant. Also, it will resist odors and will not chip or crack over time. You can expect it to last for an extended amount of time.

Other than that, it also comes with a nonstick surface on the top that will make it easier for you to take the baked food off the slots. It will also make it easier for you to clean the unit as no food residues are going to get embedded on the surface.

The unit comes with six standard-sized wells. Each of them is 3 inches in diameter and 1.25 inches deep. The design of the pan will make sure that heat is transferred to each of the wells appropriately. As a result, getting proper browning on the surface will be an easy task with this pan.

As it is dishwasher safe, you will be able to clean it without any issues at all. It is also a freezer, oven, and microwave safe.

Pros

  • Resistant to stains and chipping
  • Comes with six standard-sized slots
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Can distribute the heat evenly
  • Efficient nonstick coating

Cons

  • Muffins tend not to rise properly in the wells
  • Handles are relatively narrower

4. Cuisinart AMB-12MP Chef’s Classic Nonstick Bakeware

Cuisinart AMB-12MP Chef's Classic Nonstick Bakeware

Have you ever wondered how easy it would be to bake for a large number of people with a large-sized pan?  Well, if you get this one that Cuisinart is offering, you will not have to worry about that anymore.

To begin with, it comes in three different slot number options. The options range from small and compact 6 cups to 12 cups to a staggering 24 slots. If you get the 24 slots one, you will have no trouble at all in the case of making muffins for a relatively large group of people.

Aside from the slot options, it also comes in three different colors. You will easily be able to choose the one that will blend with the rest of your kitchen wares. Each of them features a heavy-gauge aluminized steel, which makes them exceptionally durable.

The nonstick coating that these come with is Whitford xylan coating. This coating is both on the interior and the exterior of the pan. Because of that, you will not have to worry about the food residues getting embedded on the surface. Even if it does, you can easily pop it in the dishwasher and clean it up without any hassles.

Lastly, as the edges are thick rolled, you will not have to worry about them getting warped over time. Overall, this would be a good choice if what you are looking for one of the best muffin pans.

Pros

  • Comes in three different size options
  • Has a 24 cups option
  • Features a durable aluminized steel body
  • Edges are thickly rolled
  • Comes with xylan nonstick coating on both sides

Cons

  • Nonstick pan can be scraped off easily
  • Hard to clean it with hands

5. Wilton Recipe Right Non-Stick

Wilton Recipe Right Non-Stick

While most of the pans will be able to distribute the heat evenly, what most of them lacks is the ability to prevent warping. Well, Wilton kept that in mind and implemented a durable overall construction for this unit.

As we mentioned, the unit comes with a heavy-gauge steel body that has thick edges. For the durable construction and protection on the sides, you will not have to worry about it warping over time. You can expect to use it for an extended amount of time.

The heavy-gauge construction also contributes to the even distribution of the heat throughout the cup slots that it has. You can expect the doughs to bake appropriately with even browning on the exterior.

Like most of the units that are out there, this one also comes in two different slot number options. You will be able to select one from 6 cups or 12 cup options. There is also a mini-cup version of the 12 cups one, which makes this the best mini muffin pan that you can find in the market as of right now.

It also comes with an effective nonstick coating that will allow you to pick the food up from the slots easily. You will not have to worry about residues being left on the surface of the cups. The cleaning process becomes hassle-free for it being dishwasher safe. However, for the best cleaning result, washing it with hands after each use is recommended.  .

Pros

  • Features a durable overall construction
  • Implements thick edges to prevent warping
  • Come with an effective nonstick coating
  • Two different size options available
  • Dishwasher safe

Cons

  • Some units have an awkward smell out of the box
  • Cup size on the mini version might be too small for some

6. Rachael Ray 54075 Yum-o Nonstick Bakeware

Rachael Ray 54075 Yum-o Nonstick Bakeware

You might have already stumbled upon Rachel Ray wares for all the ad campaigns that they carry out. They are also known for offering reliable kitchen utensils. And this one is no exception.

Keeping the tabs up with the other units, this one also comes with a sturdy heavy-gauge steel body.  The sturdy frame will not only be able to keep up with the heavy-duty baking workloads but also will be able to prevent warping. You can use this one for an extended amount of time.

Like most of the units, it also comes in different sizes. There are 6 cups, 12 cups, and 24 cups options. Each of them comes with a grippy handle on two of the sides. The grips will make it much easier for you to maneuver it around. You will be able to get a firm grasp of the handles even when you have oven mitts on.

The units come with an enhanced nonstick coating on the exterior that will not fade away over time. This coating will not only make it easier for you to pick up the bakery items from the slots but also will make the cleaning process feel like taking a walk in the park.

Overall, this one is an excellent pick if you are looking best non stick muffin pan that is easy to maneuver around and has a 24 cups option available.

Pros

  • Features a sturdy steel body
  • Does not warp over time
  • Three different size options
  • Has grippy handles
  • Comes with enhanced nonstick coating

Cons

  • Size of the cups is relatively small for being a standard pan
  • Exerts a rubber smell when heated up for the first time

7. USA Pan (1200MF) Bakeware Cupcake and Muffin Pan

USA Pan (1200MF) Bakeware Cupcake and Muffin Pan

You probably know that muffins and cupcakes are not the same. But do you know that you can bake both of them using a single pan? Yes! You will be able to make both of them using this ever so versatile pan that USA Pan is offering.

To start with, it comes in two different sizes. You will be able to select the one that you prefer from 12 well and 24 well options. There are also two options for the 24 well one. One has standard well-size, and one has the mini wells. You are getting loads of options with this one.

Each of the units will come in a commercial-grade heavy-gauge aluminum body. They are exceptionally sturdy and will be able to comply with heavy-duty baking workloads without any issues at all.

One thing that makes these stand out the most is the Americoat coating that these features on the exterior. It promotes easy release for the baked products and makes the cleaning process hassle-free. You will be able to make it squeaky clean using mild soap and a sponge.

Alongside that, the coating is also BPA, PFOA, and PTFE free. That means you will not have to worry about the surface releasing toxins when you heat the unit up in your oven.

Lastly, the body features a fluted design that will enhance the overall strength of the body and will prevent warping. It will also make sure that the heat is evenly distributed.

Pros

  • Exceptionally versatile
  • Offers a plethora of size and cup number options
  • Features a commercial-grade sturdy body
  • Comes with proprietary Americoat coating
  • BPA, PFOA, and PTFE free

Cons

  • Depth of the wells is a bit in the shallow side
  • Can not make the muffins rise up adequately

8. Baker’s Advantage 5111815 Nonstick Mini Muffin Pan

Baker's Advantage 5111815 Nonstick Mini Muffin Pan

Are you looking for a pan that comes with mini-sized wells? Want something that will allow you to bake for a large number of people quickly. Then you should definitely pick up this one that is from Baker’s Advantage. It does bring some advantages to the table that most of the units can not provide.

First of all, the unit comes with a durable carbon steel construction. It is 0.4 millimeters thick, and for that, it will be able to transfer the heat around through the entire body efficiently. You will not have to worry about eating undercooked doughs anymore.

Other than that, the unit comes infused with silicone on the exterior. The silicone coating acts as a nonstick coating. It will make it easier for you to release baked goods out of it. Also, it will make it easier for you to clean the unit. Food residues will easily come off the surface.

The silicone coating is also free of PFOA. You will not have to worry about it releasing harmful chemicals when you heat the unit up. This coating also enhances the heat conduction, which will ensure even baking.

As the pan comes with 24 cups, you will be able to bake for a large group of people without any issues at all. Cleaning it will not be any hassle too because it is dishwasher safe. You can also put it inside a freezer without any worries.

Pros

  • Has a staggering 24 wells
  • Can evenly distribute heat to each of the wells
  • Comes with an efficient nonstick coating
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Durable overall construction

Cons

  • Some units come with greasy machine oil covered on the wells
  • Bottom of the muffins tend to have a dark browning

9. Circulon 46014 Nonstick Bakeware

Circulon 46014 Nonstick Bakeware

When working with heated baking wares, many tend to wear oversized oven mitts. With those, getting a good amount of grip on the handles can be a little bit tricky. But, Circulon factored that in and implemented an innovative design that will make handling this pan easier.

Let us start by talking about the build quality. It comes with a heavy-gauge steel body that is exceptionally durable. The rolled rims that it features will not only make the unit look beautiful but also will prevent warping that most of the pans suffer from.

Apart from that, it comes with wide-sized handles on two of the sides. Because of those, you will be able to get a confident grip of the unit even when you have oven mitts on your hands. You will not have to worry about dropping it that much.

As it comes with 12 cup design, you will be able to bake a large number of muffins on it at one go. The size and the depth of the cups are standard too. It comes in three different color options, and all of them will blend exceptionally well with the rest of your wares.

The surface of the pan comes with a premium nonstick coating. That bottom of the wells is slightly raised, and you will be able to make your food release without any hassles at all.

Cleaning it will not be an issue too. The unit is dishwasher safe, and for the nonstick coating, food residues will easily come off the surface.

Pros

  • Implements a wide handle design
  • Easy to maneuver around
  • Three different colors
  • Has 12 standard-sized wells
  • Comes with premium nonstick coating

Cons

  • Color coating can chip easily
  • Nonstick coating loses its efficiency over time

10. Farberware 47742 Nonstick Bakeware 2 Piece

Farberware 47742 Nonstick Bakeware 2 Piece

Do you know what is better than having one best non stick muffin pan with you? Having two of them! And you will not have to get them separately if you opt for this set that is from Farberware. It offers an excellent value proposition.

Just like the label states, the set comes with two muffin pans. Each of the have 12 slots, and you will be able to make 24 muffins at one go. Having this set around will make it much easier for you in case of baking for a large number of people at parties.

Besides that, the units are durable too. They are of heavy-duty aluminized steel and will be able to meet up with the demands of heavy-duty kitchen workloads. This material will also be able to distribute the heat evenly to each of the cups. That means you are going to get perfectly brown crusts on your muffins.

Alongside that, the units come with thick sides, which will prevent warping. The large handles that these come along will make it easier for you to maneuver them around. You will have a firm grip of them even with wearing oven mitts.

Other than that, both the inside and the outside units also come with a nonstick coating. Because of that, taking out the baked foods from the slots will not be an issue. This coating will also make the cleaning process hassle-free.

Pros

  • Comes in a set of two
  • Each of the units has 12 wells
  • Distributes heat evenly on each of the wells
  • Nonstick coating on both inside and outside
  • Easy to clean

Cons

  • Not dishwasher safe
  • Size of the wells is not standard

Is There a Difference Between a Cupcake Pan and a Muffin Pan?

Muffins and cupcakes are not the same things. While one is a bit sweet and softer, the other one is a bit coarser and healthier. The healthier one is a muffin, of course. Now, the elephant in the room is whether than pans that are used are the same or not. Let us dive a little bit deeper to understand if they are the same or not.

Similarities

Yes, you will be able to make muffins in a cupcake pan and cupcake in a muffin pan. However, you will have to factor in that muffins are generally compact and are relatively smaller than cupcakes. For that reason, if you are using a cupcake pan, you will have to put the dough inside the wells accordingly.

Differences

The only thing that makes muffins pans stand out among cupcake pans is the tweaking that is done on them. For the muffin pans, the slots are a bit wider, and the spacing between each of the slots is bit broad. This broad spacing will provide you the required amount of space for making the top of the muffins for spreading.

Muffin Pan

Other than that, the slots also have a shallow lip for the muffin pans. This lip will allow you to get a large top, but the overall size will perfectly round.

Lastly, for the muffin pans, an effective nonstick coating is necessary. As the batter will usually have a large amount of flour and less amount of cooking oil, they can stick with the surface easily.

How Do I Choose a Muffin Pan?

You might already have a general idea about the things that you can expect from a decent pan after going through our best muffin pans reviews. To solidify that idea a bit more, we are here to provide you some factors that you should factor in before you make a purchase. The points that you should consider are:

Build Quality

The first thing that you have to consider is the overall build quality. As you are mostly going to use this pan for baking muffins every now and then, you would want to get something that is well built.

Keeping that in mind, we would suggest you go for the ones that come with durable construction. And the ones that come with aluminized steel and carbonized steel body are the most durable.

Muffin Pan

For the silicone ones, make sure that it is thick enough that it can hold its shape when you are moving it around with muffins on top of it. The ones that have a steel frame integrated on the body are the ones that you should shoot for. You will have a clear idea about them by going through the one that we included in our silicone muffin pan review.

Cup Numbers

After you have considered the build quality, you should also factor in the number of slots. If you plan to bake for a small number of people or for yourself only, you should be fine with something that comes with six slots.

However, if you plan to make muffins for a large group, we would suggest you go for the ones that have 12 or 24 slots.

Other than the number of slots, you should also consider the size of the cups. Most of them will have a standard size, but if you are planning to bake miniature versions, you should for the mini muffin pan.

Nonstick Coating

The nonstick coating is an important factor for muffin pans. As the dough is mostly of flour, it will tend to stick to the surface that you are going to bake.

But if you get one that comes with an efficient nonstick coating, you will not have to worry about fighting with sticky food residues anymore. Those will make it effortless for you to take the baked item out of the slots.

Cleaning

The last thing that you should consider to get the best muffin pans is the cleaning procedure. There are many that will be dishwasher safe, and those are the ones that are easy to clean.

However, if the unit comes with an efficient nonstick coating, you will have no trouble at all in case of cleaning it with hand. So if you prefer to have the convenience of hassle-free cleaning, you should opt for the ones that are dishwasher safe.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Are silicone muffin pans worth the money?

Yes, the ones that come can hold its shape together and has a good nonstick property induced are definitely worth it. They are fairly popular too and for that reason, silicone muffin pan reviews is a common topic for the people that are looking for a muffin pan.

2. Should I go for muffin pans that have a large number of slots on it?

Having more amount of slots means that you will be able to bake a large number of muffins at one go if you prefer. But do make sure that if your oven can accommodate them or not.

3. Are mini muffin pans worth it?

The best mini muffin pans will allow you to make miniature-sized muffins for your kids to enjoy. So if you have kids around, those are going to be a good investment.

4. Can I bake cupcakes in a muffin pan?

Yes, you will be able to make cupcakes in a muffin pan. But the shape of them would be like a muffin.

5. What should I use to clean muffin pans?

If you want to clean these pans with your hands, we would recommend using mild soap and a soft brush or a sponge.

Final Words

Having the best muffin pan will allow you to get muffins that will be perfectly risen and will be perfectly cooked. And we hope that we were able to make choosing one much easier for you. With that, we would like to wrap our silicone muffin pans reviews here by wishing you good luck and hoping that the muffins that you bake have proper brown crusts.