How to Make Cool Whip Frosting Thicker

How to Make Cool Whip Frosting Thicker?

Cool Whip frosting is a popular topping for many dessert items as it looks good and adds a sugary taste to the dessert. However, people who have used Cool Whip frosting before know of some of the difficulties of adding it to cupcakes. While it is light and fluffy, they aren’t thick and don’t last for a long time, often melting.

However, there are methods to making Cool Whip frosting thicker and allow it to last longer. This article will explore some of the methods to teach you how to make cool whip frosting thicker.

Alterations in Flavour

The methods listed in these articles often involve mixing in specific ingredients to help make the frosting thicker and last longer. Where possible, the methods make use of flavorless ingredients so that there are no alterations to the flavor while achieving the desired thickness.

Make Cool Whip Frosting Thicker

However, this is not possible for some ingredients and is something you should keep in mind when using the methods. In some cases, you might want to change the flavor, and so it might prove useful.

How to Make Cool Whip Frosting Thicker

Here, we’ll talk about the methods that you can apply.

Cool Whip Frosting Thicker

1. Adding Powdered Sugar and Cornstarch

While the first method mentions two ingredients, you can opt to use either one of them depending on your needs. Powdered sugar and cornstarch are both effective at stabilizing and thickening your cool whip frosting. Cornstarch does this by absorbing the liquid in the mix and thus making the frosting less runny.

Powdered sugar also contains cornstarch, which allows it to do the same job but also sweeten the frosting. This is why you can use both or even one of them depending on your needs.

Powdered Sugar and Cornstarch

If your frosting is sweet enough or you don’t want to make it sweeter, simply add 2 teaspoons of cornstarch. And if you want to make your frosting sweeter and more consistent at the same time, just add 2 teaspoons of powdered sugar.

2. Mixing in Cream Cheese

The second method involves adding cream cheese to the frosting. Cream cheese is a viable choice in making your cool whip frosting thicker and consistent. However, it should be noted that cream cheese alters the flavor of your frosting. Adding cream cheese will make your frosting have a creamier and tangy taste.

Mixing in Cream Cheese

While cream cheese is effective, whether or not you’ll resort to using this method primarily depends on whether you like a creamy frosting or a more sugary one.

However, if you want to use cream cheese, you can also mix in some vanilla extract and sugar to retain more of the sweet and sugary goodness of your frosting while also ensuring that it doesn’t melt easily.

3. Adding Yogurt

Yogurt is a good stabilizing agent and can be used with cool whip frosting along with some milk. Do note that it can alter the taste and flavor of your especially if a bit too much is added, so be careful with it. If you plan to add yogurt to your frosting mix, remember to use fewer liquids, or you might end up making it runny.

Adding Yogurt

It is recommended to thin out the yogurt with milk before using it. One advantage of using yogurt is that it helps the frosting keep its shape when refrigerated.


In case you don’t want to use yogurt, other ingredients work similarly. Buttermilk is a good option to use, but do note it does result in an acidic taste if used too much.

4. Using Jell-O Powder

It might sound surprising, but the Jell-O powder is also great at making Cool Whip frosting much thicker. It’s also a good way to give your frosting a unique flavor; however, there is also flavorless Jell-O powder, so you can simply use it as a stabilizing agent for your Cool Whip frosting.

This will allow your frosting to last longer.

Using Jell-O Powder


Powdered pudding is a good alternative for this, with vanilla being a popular flavor and makes your frosting thicker.


Cool Whip frosting can give some people difficulties since it melts so easily, but with these methods, you can make the frosting thicker and make it last longer at room temperature.

You can also add some personal touches to your frostings by giving them unique flavors while making them consistent.

Now that you know how to make Cool Whip frosting thicker, you should start baking.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *